This is under My Profile > Account:
You can see the Province Field. I select out a value:
then select Update Profile it, it goes back to unselected:
This is all on the My Profile page - they are not using the Profile Builder plugin you mentioned above, they are using all the wpForo plugins:
Under wpForo > Members these are the fields:
This is the Province field expanded:
Going back to the Profile, if I update the Industry:
It shows the updated field once I save it:
So, I am not sure what Profile Builder has to do with this, we are not using that plugin, we are using the custom fields add on for your plugin.